Elrond likely did not stop Isildur from taking the Ring of Power for a few reasons. Firstly, Elrond had little reason to believe that Isildur was not a reliable or powerful enough leader to wield the Ring responsibly.
As the son of Elendil, Isildur was part of a great lineage and held a high position in the Fellowship. Elrond could not have predicted that Isildur would become corrupted by the Ring, as the full extent of the Ring’s power was unknown at the time.
Additionally, Elrond was not in a position of power at that point in time. He was part of the Fellowship which was only just beginning its quest and ultimately had to answer to Isildur, as the leader of the quest.
Elrond likely did not believe he had any authority to stop Isildur from taking the Ring. Even if Elrond had wanted to stop Isildur, any such attempt may have been futile as Isildur would have likely overruled him or fled with the Ring regardless.
Ultimately, Elrond had good intentions in entrusting Isildur with the Ring but, unfortunately, could not have foreseen the consequences that would follow.
Table of Contents
Why didn t Elrond kill Isildur to destroy the Ring?
Elrond did not kill Isildur to destroy the Ring because Isildur was the rightful heir of the kingdom of Gondor and Elrond was deeply aware of the tremendous power the Ring held. If Elrond were to kill Isildur and leave the Ring in his hands, he knew it would fall into the wrong hands and corrupt whoever held it, or worse, summon a powerful and dark force to retrieve it.
Elrond instead attempted to convince Isildur to destroy the Ring and with it, break its powerful spell, but Isildur chose to keep it for himself for its potential financial and political wealth. Knowing that the Ring had already claimed too many lives and caused too much destruction, Elrond chose to leave Isildur to his own fate and protect his family and kingdom from the power of the Ring.
Did Isildur refuse to destroy the Ring?
Yes, Isildur refused to destroy the Ring. After defeating Sauron in the Battle of Dagorlad and cutting off his finger with the Ring, Isildur was given the opportunity by the Council of Elrond to destroy the Ring by throwing it into the fire of Mount Doom in Mordor.
He was warned that it should be destroyed, as it was a source of great power and could corrupt anyone who held it, but Isildur refused the offer and kept the Ring instead. Throughout his life, Isildur encountered temptation and was corrupted by the Ring’s power, ultimately leading to his downfall and death.
It was not until thousands of years later that the Ring was eventually destroyed by the sheer will of the hero, Frodo Baggins.
Why didn t Galadriel tell Elrond about Halbrand?
Galadriel likely chose not to tell Elrond about Halbrand for two reasons. First, Galadriel was attempting to keep the tragedy of her daughter Celebrían and Halbrand as private as possible. Celebrían had been passing through Lórien and was attacked by Orcs, who then held her captive.
Halbrand then risked his life to rescue Celebrían and was severely injured in the process. Galadriel may have been hoping to keep the pain and suffering of her daughter’s experience as private as possible and was likely hesitant to share the story with Elrond.
Second, Galadriel was, in many ways, at odds with Elrond, as she was more resistant to standing with the party of the White Council, which included Elrond, to stand against Sauron and his forces–and even less enthusiastic about the idea of a Ring-Bearer.
Galadriel even told Elrond off in his own home, which illustrated her desire not to be influenced by Elrond’s opinions and his wariness of Sauron. Thus, she may not have felt comfortable sharing the story of her daughter and Halbrand with him, or perhaps revealed only vague details of what had happened to Elrond but not the full story.
As she withheld the identity of Halbrand and the details of the story from Elrond, this may indicate her desire to keep it closer to her heart.
Did Elrond know about the Ring?
Yes, Elrond knew about the Ring. As one of the wise, ancient elves of Middle-Earth, Elrond had heard stories of the Rings of Power and their potential hazards. In particular, he had heard tales of Sauron, the Dark Lord and his One Ring.
By the time of Bilbo Baggins and company’s arrival to Rivendell, Elrond had already pieced together that the magical Ring Bilbo had found was the One Ring. He was aware of its power and the potential danger it posed to Middle-Earth.
Elrond was the one who suggested that Bilbo should leave the Ring to Frodo Baggins and said that Frodo should eventually take it to Mordor and destroy it. Elrond understood the power and consequences of the Ring better than anyone in the Fellowship, and was ultimately proven right when Frodo succeeded in his mission to destroy the Ring.
Why couldn’t Sauron find the Ring in the river?
Sauron could not find the Ring in the river because the Ring had been taken by the creature Gollum and borne away in secret. Gollum had gone off into the Misty Mountains, running and hiding from all who pursued him.
The river was too deep and wide for Sauron to search, and the Ring was too small to be seen. In addition, it had a powerful enchantment upon it which would have prevented Sauron from even sensing its presence.
Sauron’s main focus was centered upon the Shire, where the Ring had last been seen, so it was unlikely he would have searched the river even if he had known of its existence. Ultimately, the Ring remained hidden for centuries until it was found by Bilbo Baggins and eventually destroyed by Frodo Baggins.
Why wasn t Galadriel at the Council of Elrond?
Galadriel was not at the Council of Elrond because she was too far away. As a powerful Elven ruler and leader, she lived at the northern edge of Middle-earth in central western Eriador, known as Lothlórien.
This area was too far away for her to make the journey and join the Council of Elrond that was held in Rivendell, some three hundred and fifty miles away. In addition, her presence at the Council would have been a distraction, as her considerable power and wisdom would have overshadowed the other members of the Council.
As a result, she chose to remain in Lothlórien while sending a message through the Eagle Gwaihir that conveyed her thoughts, opinions and support of the only way that could save Middle-earth from the dark presence of Sauron.
What if Elrond took the One Ring?
If Elrond took the One Ring, it could have had disastrous consequences. Elrond was one of the most powerful Elves in Middle-earth, and he had been living for thousands of years. He had the knowledge and power to use the Ring for evil purposes, which is why Sauron wanted to keep the Ring close and out of his hands.
Taking the Ring would have been a corruptive force for Elrond, and likely have driven him mad as it did so many others. It also could have given him the power necessary to take over Middle-earth as Sauron wished to do.
The fact that Elrond didn’t take the Ring ( despite being tempted to do so) was one of the key factors that allowed the Fellowship of the Ring to have the chance to destroy it.
What is the most famous line in Lord of the Rings?
The most famous line from “The Lord of the Rings” is “One Ring to rule them all, One Ring to find them, One Ring to bring them all and in the darkness bind them. ” This memorable line is spoken by Gandalf when the One Ring is first revealed in The Fellowship of the Ring, the first volume of “The Lord of the Rings”.
The line speaks to the fact that when Sauron — the main antagonist — is in possession of the One Ring, all of Middle-earth is at risk of falling under his control. In effect, the power of the One Ring is such that it can put all the other rings of power and the creatures of Middle-earth in danger, subverting their will and turning them into followers of Sauron.
This serves as both a warning of the consequences of Sauron’s return and a hint at the Fellowship’s mission to destroy the Ring and stop Sauron.
What did narsil mean?
Narsil was a sword of immense power in Tolkien’s Middle-earth mythology. It was created by Eöl, a Dark Elf, and was powerful enough to defeat Sauron, the main antagonist. The sword Narsil was first presented to Elendil, the High King of Gondor, during the War of the Last Alliance.
When Isildur cut the One Ring from Sauron’s finger with the sword’s blade, Narsil was broken in two.
The name Narsil is derived from the Quenya Elvish language, Sara, meaning “red and glorious flame”. The sword can be seen as a symbol of power, courage, and hope, as it was used to fight evil and restore peace across Middle-earth.
It represented the strength of the free peoples of Middle-earth who banded together to fight against Sauron’s tyranny. Ultimately, Narsil was a symbol for the victory of good over evil and the re-establishment of order and justice.
What is the relationship between Isildur and Elrond?
Isildur and Elrond were both part of the same family, descended from Elros, the brother of Elrond. Technically Elrond was Isildur’s uncle, as he was the son of Elrond’s brother. Isildur was the eldest son of Elendil, which made him the second King of Gondor after his father’s death.
Isildur and Elrond have an even closer relationship in the Lord of the Rings, however. They both served alongside each other in the Last Alliance against Sauron’s forces during the War of the Last Alliance.
It was in this war that Isildur used Narsil, a broken sword wielded by Elendil, to defeat Sauron, becoming the Heir of Elendil.
After their victory in the War of the Last Alliance, Isildur had Narsil reforged and became the new bearer of the sword. When it was time for Isildur to return to Gondor, Elrond presented him with a small vial which contained the one Ring given to Isildur by Sauron.
Throughout the third age, Isildur and Elrond were both involved in the war against Sauron and his allies. After Isildur’s death in TA2, Elrond, along with two other Elven lords, were appointed to protect and maintain the destroyed kingdom of Arnor.
They divided the kingdom of Arnor into three, becoming the leaders of the North, South, and West.
In the end, Isildur and Elrond were close friends and allies in the fight against evil. Isildur served as the Heir of Elendil, defended Gondor, and prevented Sauron from reclaiming the Ring. Elrond held a special place in Isildur’s heart, as he had served with him in the Last Alliance, was the one to provide him with the Ring, and help him maintain Arnor after Isildur’s passing.
How old was Isildur when he died?
Isildur was about 90 years old when he died. He was the son of Elendil, who was about 160 years old at the time of Isildur’s death. Isildur was born in TA 2262 and died in TA 2441, so he lived for about 179 years.
He had been ruling over the kingdom of Arnor since TA 2259, which was two years prior to his father’s death, so he was around 81 years old when he ascended the throne – making him approximately 90 when he died.
Why did the Ring abandon Isildur?
The Ring of Power abandoned Isildur for two main reasons: its allure was too great, and Isildur failed to destroy it. As the Ring was forged by Sauron and infused with some of his power, it had a strong hold on its wearer.
Even Isildur, who had seen its corrupting powers, could not resist its allure. He refused to destroy the Ring when he had the chance, instead deciding to keep it for himself. As a result, the Ring abandoned Isildur shortly afterwards, likely in response to the tug of its creator and the temptation it offered its wearer.
Though Isildur escaped drowning, it was not without loss. He was suddenly and mysteriously stripped of the Ring, which allowed Sauron to then reclaim and rebuild his strength. This eventual loss of Isildur’s Ring ultimately had huge implications for the fate of Middle-earth.
Why didn’t Isildur destroy the Ring when he could?
Isildur had the chance to destroy the Ring when he found it, yet he chose not to. This was because, in his mind, the Ring held power, and with its destruction, this power would be forever lost. In the moment that he found it, Isildur felt an attachment.
He was tempted by the Ring’s promise of power, and foolishly thought that he could use it to secure Gondor’s kingdom and make himself an even greater king than his father had been. Isildur seemingly forgot the warnings of Gandalf and the wise Elrond and instead was blinded by the potential that the Ring offered, despite it being a Dark object.
Aside from this, the Ring, being one of the Three Rings of the Elves, may have provided Isildur with a sense of connection. Along with this, being on the brink of a great battle, the thought of being able to secure the victory with the Ring’s power would have been too great a temptation for Isildur, who most likely thought he couldn’t risk sacrificing the power it held.
