Ned lied about Jon’s parentage in order to protect him from the potential danger of being exposed as a trueborn Stark. Ned was honor-bound to protect his exiled and disgraced sister Lyanna and believed the only way to do that was to keep the secret of Jon’s birth, even though it meant sacrificing his own reputation and credibility.
He also wanted to protect Jon from the potential danger of other powerful forces in the realm who may want to hurt him if they knew his true identity. On top of that, leaving aside the truth about Jon’s mother would bestow him with an immediate legitimacy in the eyes of others, shielding him from discrimination or mistrust.
Table of Contents
Does Catelyn Stark ever find out about Jon Snow?
Yes, Catelyn Stark eventually finds out about Jon Snow. After Ned and his party are taken prisoner at Kings Landing, Catelyn sends a message back to Winterfell to tell her son, Robb Stark, of the dire situation.
During this time, news has also reached Winterfell of Ned’s illegitimate son, Jon Snow, and Catelyn is determined to get to the truth of Jon’s parentage. After Robb and Catelyn’s sister, Lysa Arryn, join forces, they plan to bring Ned back and find out the truth about Jon.
After a long time, finally Catelyn gets to meet Jon at Winterfell, upon Ned’s return from Kings Landing. From that moment on, she knows he is her husband’s son, and she loves him like her own.
Did Benjen know Jon was a Targaryen?
Based on the available evidence, it is not clear whether or not Benjen Stark knew that Jon Snow was a Targaryen. Benjen does not seem to know of Jon’s parentage. For instance, when Benjen tells Jon to take back Winterfell and become Lord of Winterfell, he talks about how the North is in need of a Stark to be its leader and how Jon is uniquely suited to the task since he carries a Stark name.
If Benjen had known that Jon was a Targaryen, it seems likely he would have said something. Moreover, Benjen only learns Rhaegar Targaryen is Jon’s father after he already passes away.
That said, there are also some hints that Benjen may have had some inkling of Jon’s true identity. During their time together beyond the wall, Benjen is exceptionally kind to Jon and willing to protect him.
He also defends Jon’s reputation throughout their travels and imparts lessons on leadership and courage—which may have suggested that he saw greatness within Jon. Finally, it is notable that Benjen could have revealed to Jon the truth about his family, yet never does.
Ultimately, the answer to whether or not Benjen knew about Jon’s heritage remains unclear. Fans will just have to continue speculating.
Is Jon Snow the most like Ned?
No, Jon Snow is not the most like Ned. Jon Snow is the bastard son of Ned Stark, but they had different upbringings and personalities. Ned was an honorable and principled man who always made sure to do the right thing.
He was a loving father and loyal friend, but also a formidable leader in battles. Jon, on the other hand, had more of a tumultuous upbringing. While Jon is also very honorable and tries to do the right thing, he often faces difficult decisions and has a more emotional approach to situations.
He is also a formidable fighter, but his sword skills tend to be more intuitive than planned. Overall, Jon Snow and Ned Stark have many similarities, but also distinct differences that make them two separate individuals.
Did Ned Stark know Jon Snow wasn’t his son?
No, Ned Stark never found out that Jon Snow was not his son. He had always believed that Jon Snow was his legitimate son, born to his wife, Catelyn Stark, who had never betrayed him. It was only when Ned Stark journeyed south to King’s Landing that he learned the truth about Jon Snow’s true parentage from one of his closest confidants, Maester Aemon.
Even then, with Catelyn dead and Ned’s life threatened, he kept the information to himself and was never able to tell Jon the truth before his untimely death.
Why didn’t Lady Stoneheart appear in the show?
Lady Stoneheart, the vengeful and undead version of Catelyn Stark, didn’t appear in the show because it was determined by series showrunners David Benioff and D. B. Weiss that the character didn’t have enough of an impact on the plot of the show to spend time developing her character.
Also, because of the characters’ non-canon timeline in the show, it was difficult to include her in the ongoing plot-lines. Considering that her role would have had to be extended to accommodate the show and adapted to fit her role into the arc, the showrunners felt it was better to use the existing source material instead.
Additionally, the producers felt that her presence in the show would not significantly alter the main plot, so they chose to focus their energy on other characters rather than introducing her. Ultimately, the showrunners determined that if the character was not going to help move the plot along by having a major impact in the show, then introducing her would merely be a distraction.
What does Lyanna whisper to Ned?
The exact words that Lyanna whispered to Ned in George R. R. Martin’s A Song of Ice and Fire series were never revealed to readers. The show Game of Thrones slightly altered the scene and in this version, Lyanna whispers “Promise me, Ned”.
For fans of the series, this has become somewhat of an enigma since the exact words that Lyanna whispered to Ned remain a mystery.
In some fan theories, it is speculated that Lyanna whispered “Robert is not the father” to Ned, referring to her son, Jon Snow. This could indicate that Lyanna had an affair with someone else and that Ned was aware of this.
Other fans believe that Lyanna whispered “Protect him” or “Protect Jon”. This suggests that Ned was already aware of the fact that Jon was his nephew, and that Lyanna was entrusting her brother with her son’s protection in the world of Westeros.
The truth is that we may never know what Lyanna whispers to Ned, as it is not made clear in either the book or TV series. Fans continue to speculate and analyze the different versions of the scene in an effort to discover Lyanna’s whispered words.
How did Catelyn feel about Jon?
Catelyn Stark had a complicated relationship with her husband’s bastard son, Jon Snow. Despite her initial resentment towards Jon due to his parentage, Catelyn grew to love him as if he were one of her own children.
She tried to fill in the gap of a mother figure in his life, offering him words of wisdom and support whenever needed. Catelyn truly came to care for Jon, viewing him as family, despite the opposition she faced from others in her household.
She went out of her way to ensure his safety and future wellbeing, even digging through Robert Baratheon’s records to discover a potential last name for him. It was clear that Catelyn was deeply fond of Jon and sorely missed him after he left Winterfell for the Night’s Watch.
Her affection for him was evident in the respect she showed him and her love for him was always genuine.
Who was Ned’s Favourite child?
Ned Stark was a loving father who was devoted to all his children and it is unclear who his favorite was. He had five children who grew up in Winterfell, and each of them had very different personalities and special qualities that he adored.
He imparted different life lessons to each of them and seemed to have a close bond with all of them. His eldest son, Robb, was his heir and Ned watched him with great pride. He often took Robb on hunting trips, teaching him the skills he would need to be a great leader.
His second son, Bran, was dearly loved by Ned and was often heard murmuring how proud he was of him. Sansa, his eldest daughter, was Ned’s precious little princess, and he indulged her with bright smiles and compliments on her beauty.
Arya, his second daughter, was a wild child, and he was proud of her spunk and was always encouraging her to stand up for herself and be independent. And lastly, his youngest son Jon was his youngest, special one, and Ned had a close bond with him, teaching him the lessons he would need to be a great leader.
With each of his children, Ned demonstrated his love in unique ways, so it is hard to pinpoint any favorite among them.
What was Ned’s mistake?
Ned’s mistake was to trust Robert Baratheon, and by proxy, Cersei Lannister. He trusted them, not only by believing they would uphold their promise of appointing him as Hand of the King, but he also trusted that they wouldn’t manipulate him.
By the end of Season 1, Ned had come under the thumb of Cersei, who tricked him into accepting Robert’s offer of Varys’ false information. He was made aware of Cersei’s plan of offering him the Hand of the King role then revealing the false information to prove his treachery with her brother, Jaime.
Despite his chances of survival being few, he accepted his life as a way of redeeming himself from helping start a war and tarnishing his honour. His mistake was ultimately trusting those around him and neglecting to double check the validity of his sources.
Unfortunately, this mistake led down a path which ended in Ned’s eventual capture and death.
Did Ned know about Lyanna and Rhaegar?
No, it appears that Ned Stark did not know about the affair between Lyanna and Rhaegar until after Lyanna’s death, when Howland Reed revealed the truth to Ned. Up until this point, Ned had believed that Lyanna had been kidnapped and held against her will by Rhaegar, and his mission in the Tower of Joy was to rescue her.
In the respective books, Lyanna’s brother, Brandon, was sent to King’s Landing by Ned to demand her return, while Ned and his bannermen went to the Tower of Joy in search of her. After the confrontation between Ned and his allies and Rhaegar’s remaining loyal Kingsguard at the Tower of Joy, Ned and his friends discovered Lyanna in a bed of blood.
It was at that point when Howland Reed revealed to Ned that Lyanna and Rhaegar had exchange wedding vowels, revealing the truth about their affair. From Ned’s reaction, it was clear that he had been unaware of the secret affair.
Who is Jon Snow’s twin sister?
Jon Snow’s twin sister is named Arya Stark. She was born shortly after Jon to their parents Eddard “Ned” Stark and Catelyn Stark at the Stark ancestral home of Winterfell. Arya Stark is a fierce, independent and determined young woman who often takes risks to achieve her goals.
She is highly skilled at sword fighting and has been trained by a variety of teachers including Syrio Forel, Jaqen H’ghar, and the Faceless Men. She’s known for taking a moral stand against the powerful and is driven to punish those who have wronged her family.
Arya’s journey started out as a quest for revenge, but has since evolved into a mission to protect her family and the people of Westeros from tyranny. Along the way, Arya has made a number of allies, including the Hound, Gendry, and the Brotherhood Without Banners.
She has also become increasingly important to the overall story line, serving as an important reminder that one person can make a difference in a world full of powerful houses and their respective agendas.
Did Ned know Jon was the heir to the throne?
No, Ned Stark did not know Jon Snow was the true heir to the Iron Throne. At the time that he knew Jon, he believed he was his bastard son, born illegitimately to his wife’s sister, Lyanna Stark. Lyanna had confided in Ned before her death that Jon was actually the son of her and Prince Rhaegar Targaryen, brother to the Mad King and rightful heir to the throne.
Although Ned suspected that Jon was in fact Rhaegar and Lyanna’s son, the truth wasn’t revealed to him until after the War of the Five Kings. Bran Stark learned the truth when he arrived at the Tower of Joy and saw his father telling his dying aunt Lyanna of a promise he made to her and informing her that he would take care of Jon.
After Ned’s death, Jon was then revealed as the true heir to the Iron Throne by Samwell Tarly and training that Daenerys Targaryen had to be the one to take the throne.
