The concept of gender has been around for thousands of years, but the modern understanding of gender as a social and cultural construct rather than a biological one only emerged in the mid-20th century. The first person to use the term “gender” in this sense was John Money, a psychologist and sexologist who was part of the team that conducted the now-infamous experiment on David Reimer in the 1960s.
Money argued that gender was a separate thing from sex, and that it was learned through socialization rather than being innate. He used the terms “gender identity” and “gender role” to describe the different aspects of gender, and his work had a significant influence on feminist and queer theorists in the following decades.
However, it’s important to note that the concept of gender has been present in different cultures and societies throughout history. Many Native American cultures, for example, recognized multiple gender identities and roles beyond the traditional male/female binary. Similarly, transgender and gender-nonconforming individuals have been documented in many cultures and time periods, even if they weren’t always accepted or understood in the same way we understand those concepts now.
So while John Money may have been the first to articulate the modern understanding of gender as a social construct, the concept itself has much deeper roots in human history and culture.
Table of Contents
Who started gender identity?
The concept of gender identity has been present in societies for centuries, although it was not until recent times that it became a widely used term in academic and social discourse. It is difficult to attribute the origin of gender identity to a single person or culture, as different societies and peoples have had varying beliefs and understandings of gender throughout history.
However, some scholars trace the roots of contemporary gender identity theories to early feminist and lesbian activists who challenged traditional gender norms and roles in the 1960s and 1970s. These thinkers, such as Judith Butler, argued that gender is not a fixed, essential attribute but rather a performance or social construct that is shaped by cultural and historical factors.
They critiqued the idea that gender is biologically determined, and instead proposed that it is a fluid and flexible identity that can change over time.
Additionally, the rise of trans activism and advocacy in the late 20th century created greater awareness of gender variance and nonbinary identities. Trans individuals have long faced discrimination and marginalization in society, but their activism and advocacy have contributed to broader acceptance and recognition of diverse gender identities.
While it is difficult to pinpoint a singular individual or group who began the concept of gender identity, it is clear that it has been shaped by generations of thinkers, activists, and communities who have challenged and expanded traditional understandings of gender.
How did gender identity develop?
Gender identity is a deeply ingrained aspect of our individual identities which refers to our sense of self as male, female, or non-binary. It is not exclusively determined by biological anatomy or sex chromosomes. Instead, it is developed through complex interactions between genetic, environmental, and cultural factors that shape our subjective experiences of gender.
During the early years of development, infants form attachments with their primary caregivers and begin to develop a sense of trust in the world around them. At this time, studies have found that children show strong preferences for gender-conforming toys and behaviors. These preferences appear to be influenced by both socialization and biology, with prenatal hormone exposure playing a particular role in shaping gender-related preferences (e.g., boys’ tendency towards trucks, girls’ attraction to dolls).
However, research suggests that these preferences are malleable and can be influenced by exposure to atypical gender models.
Around the age of two, children begin to develop a language for understanding and expressing their gender identity. This can involve identifying themselves as a boy or girl, or expressing a more fluid sense of gender that does not fit neatly into a binary. As children grow older, their gender identities become more complex and nuanced, influenced by social messages, family dynamics, and personal experiences of gender.
Interactions with peers, family members, and other members of society also play a critical role in shaping children’s gender identity and gender roles. For example, socialization processes often reinforce gender stereotypes and promote traditional gender roles. This can create a sense of tension for children who may feel that their interests and self-expression do not align with the expected norms for their gender.
As individuals continue to develop throughout their lives, their gender identities can shift and evolve in response to changing circumstances and experiences. Some individuals may also experience a disconnect between their biological sex and gender identity, leading them to identify as transgender or non-binary.
Gender identity is a complex and multifaceted concept that develops through a combination of biological, social, and cultural factors. It is influenced by both individual experiences and broader societal messages about gender. Understanding the development of gender identity is critical for promoting healthy gender expression and creating a more equitable and inclusive society.
When did we start using gender?
The concept of gender has been present in human societies for centuries, but the specific classification of individuals based on gender is a relatively recent development. Historically, gender roles were largely based on biological sex, with men typically occupying positions of power and authority, and women relegated to domestic tasks and child-rearing.
However, in many societies, there were also individuals who did not conform to these traditional gender roles, such as those who identified as third genders, or those who engaged in same-sex relationships.
It was not until the late 19th and early 20th centuries that the term gender began to be used in its modern sense, as a way of distinguishing between biological sex and cultural gender. This development was largely driven by feminist and queer theorists who sought to challenge traditional gender roles and sexual norms, and to promote the idea that gender is a social construct rather than a biological fact.
One of the earliest proponents of this view was the pioneering sexologist Magnus Hirschfeld, who founded the Scientific-Humanitarian Committee in Germany in 1897 to advocate for LGBT rights and to advance the idea that same-sex attraction was not a mental illness. Hirschfeld argued that gender was a complex and multi-dimensional phenomenon that could not be reduced to simple biological categories, and that individuals should be allowed to express their gender identity in ways that felt authentic to them.
Despite these early efforts to expand the concept of gender, it was not until the 1960s and 1970s that the idea of gender as a social and cultural construct gained wider acceptance. Feminist theorists such as Simone de Beauvoir and Judith Butler argued that gender was not simply an innate characteristic of individuals, but rather a product of social and historical forces that shaped our understanding of what it meant to be male or female.
Today, the concept of gender continues to evolve, with many individuals and communities advocating for greater acceptance of diverse gender identities and expressions. While there is still much work to be done in achieving true gender equality, it is clear that the concept of gender has come a long way since its early days as a simple binary classification of male or female.
What was John Money’s theory?
John Money was a well-known psychologist who proposed a theory revolving around the concept of gender identity. He believed that gender is a social construct and that society molds an individual’s perception of themselves based on their biological sex. In his theory, he suggested that external factors such as social norms, cultural influences, upbringing, and personal experiences shape an individual’s gender identity.
Money’s theory initially gained recognition following his work with the famous case of identical twins, Bruce and Brian Reimer, back in the 1960s. Bruce had been involved in a botched circumcision at a young age, and as a result, his parents were advised to have him undergo a gender reassignment surgery and raised him entirely as a girl, renamed Brenda.
Money believed that if a child was raised entirely as a girl or a boy, even if that did not match their assigned sex, it would still lead to the development of gender identity, and the individual would be able to adapt to their assigned or chosen gender in adulthood.
However, some criticisms of Money’s theory have been raised over the years. Some researchers argue that biology plays a more significant role in defining gender identity, and children will inherently identify with and behave according to their biological sex irrespective of how they are raised. Additionally, some have raised ethical concerns over the Reimer case and criticized Money for his methods.
While John Money’s theory initially gained recognition and generated discussion around the concept of gender identity, it has faced criticisms in recent years. Nevertheless, it remains a prominent theoretical framework for studying the social factors that contribute to the development of one’s gender identity.
Why was gender invented?
Gender as we understand it today was not necessarily “invented” in the traditional sense, but rather evolved over time as a way for societies to organize themselves based on perceived differences between males and females. Evolutionarily speaking, sex serves as a means of reproduction and continuation of the species, and physical differences between males and females arose to fulfill this biological imperative.
However, the social and cultural aspects of gender, such as the expectations placed on individuals based on their perceived gender, the division of labor along gender lines, and the role of gender in social hierarchies, are largely constructed by society. When people began to organize themselves into groups larger than a family, gender roles began to emerge as a way to divide labor and create a functioning society.
For example, it may have been advantageous for men to focus on hunting and defending the group, while women focused on child-rearing and gathering food.
Over time, these social expectations became linked with biological sex, and gender became seen as an innate characteristic rather than a social construct. The invention of gender as a binary system with distinct and complementary male and female roles is often attributed to European colonialism and patriarchal values that were imposed on colonized societies around the world.
This system perpetuated the idea that men and women had innate differences that dictated their abilities, preferences, and social roles.
Today, many people increasingly recognize that gender is a complex and varied concept that goes beyond a simple binary of male and female. Gender identity and expression are now understood to be shaped by a range of factors, including biology, culture, socialization, and personal choice, and we are beginning to acknowledge and accept a broader range of gender identities beyond the traditional male-female binary.
However, many societies and cultures still hold rigid and limiting ideas about gender that prevent all individuals from fully exploring and expressing their true selves.
Who is the father of gender?
The concept of gender is a complex and multifaceted one that has evolved over time. While there may not be a definitive “father” of gender in the same way that there is a recognizable figure for certain scientific or intellectual disciplines, there are certainly individuals who have played a significant role in shaping our understanding of gender and its place in society.
One of the earliest and most influential scholars to focus on gender was Simone de Beauvoir, a French writer and philosopher who argued in her seminal work The Second Sex that gender is not a natural or inherent characteristic, but rather a socially constructed identity that is imposed upon individuals based on their sex.
Beauvoir’s work challenged prevailing notions about women’s role in society and paved the way for subsequent feminist theories that sought to deconstruct and challenge patriarchal gender norms.
Another figure who is often cited as a pioneer in the field of gender studies is Judith Butler, an American philosopher whose work on gender performativity has had a significant impact on feminist and queer theory. Butler argues that gender is not a stable or intrinsic identity, but rather a set of behaviors, gestures, and acts that are constantly performed and re-performed in order to create the illusion of gender identity.
This theory has had a profound influence on the way we think about gender and has helped to highlight the ways in which gender is a complex and multifaceted construct that is intimately bound up with power and social hierarchy.
Other key figures in the development of gender theory include Michel Foucault, who explored the ways in which power and knowledge are intertwined with gender and sexuality, and bell hooks, an African American feminist writer whose work focuses on the intersection of race, gender, and class. Together, these and other thinkers have helped to shape our understanding of gender and have opened up new possibilities for challenging traditional gender norms and creating more inclusive and equitable societies.
When did genders evolve?
Genders did not necessarily evolve, as they are not a biological concept, but rather a social and cultural one. The concept of gender refers to the roles, behaviors, and expectations that societies place on individuals based on their perceived sex. While sex is determined by biology, based on physical characteristics such as genitalia and chromosomes, gender is a more complex and fluid concept.
The history of gender goes back thousands of years and varies greatly across different cultures and societies. Many early societies had more fluid concepts of gender, with multiple genders existing and individuals being able to move between them. For example, some Native American tribes recognized individuals who did not fit into traditional male or female roles as “two-spirit” or “berdache.”
However, in many cultures, patriarchal systems developed, which led to a more rigid gender binary of male and female. In these societies, masculinity and femininity were often seen as opposing forces, with men being dominant and women being submissive. These gender roles were enforced through social norms, laws, and religious beliefs, and anyone who did not conform to them was often met with discrimination and violence.
In recent decades, there has been a growing recognition of the harmful effects of rigid gender roles and a push towards greater gender equality. Many countries have enacted laws to protect individuals from discrimination based on gender identity or expression, and more and more people are pushing back against the idea that there are only two genders.
While genders themselves did not evolve, the concept of gender has a complex and varied history that is deeply influenced by social and cultural factors. As our understanding of gender continues to evolve, there is hope that we can create a world where individuals are free to express their full range of gender identities without fear of discrimination or violence.
How many sexes are there?
The concept of biological sex is often thought of as a simple binary division between male and female. However, sex is a complex biological trait that encompasses a range of physical, chromosomal, and hormonal characteristics. While most individuals are typically born with either male or female reproductive organs, there are a variety of chromosomal, developmental, and hormonal conditions that can result in what are known as intersex traits.
These conditions can include variations such as Klinefelter syndrome, Turner syndrome, and androgen insensitivity syndrome.
In addition to the traditional binary of male and female, many cultures throughout history have recognized the existence of additional genders or gender identities. Indigenous cultures in North America, for example, have long recognized the existence of individuals who do not fit comfortably into the male or female binary, often referred to as Two-Spirit or other culturally specific terms.
Other societies may recognize more than two genders, offering social and cultural frameworks for people who identify as non-binary, genderqueer, or gender nonconforming.
In recent years, the concept of gender as a social construct has come to the forefront of social discourse, with many people questioning the rigid gender norms that have traditionally been imposed upon individuals based on their biological sex. This has led to a greater recognition of the existence of a spectrum of gender identities that are not limited to strictly male or female categories.
While the traditional binary of male and female has long been the dominant framework for understanding sex and gender, there are a variety of biological and cultural factors that can influence a person’s sex, as well as a growing recognition of the existence of non-binary genders.
What did John Money do to the twins?
John Money was a prominent psychologist and sexologist who is infamous for his unethical and controversial experiment with identical twins, Bruce Reimer and Brian Reimer. In the early 1960s, the twin brothers were born as healthy boys but unfortunately faced medical complications during circumcision.
Their penis was accidentally burnt off due to a faulty method of surgery.
Desperate to help their children, the Reimer family sought guidance from John Money, who was a known pioneer in the field of gender identity theory. Money, who firmly believed that gender was learned and not innate, convinced the Reimer family that surgery and hormone therapy could create a female gender identity in their son, Bruce.
Over the next few years, Bruce was subjected to extensive surgeries and hormone treatments, along with numerous visits to John Money’s Gender Identity Clinic. Bruce was raised as a girl, Brenda. Money monitored the Reimer family’s progress closely, and their communication allowed him to publish academic papers to advance his theory of gender neutrality.
However, the experiment had disastrous consequences. Brenda grew up feeling confused, suicidal, and unhappy with her gender. She never identified as a female and felt out of place in her body. Her parents consulted Money again, but he recommended her to continue with her therapy and counseling sessions instead of reversing her gender back to males.
Finally, when Brenda was in her late teens, she discovered the truth about her gender and underwent surgery to transition back to male. Unfortunately, the mental damage caused by John Money’s unethical experiment had already been done, and Brian Reimer also struggled with drugs and alcohol and eventually took his life.
Money’s experiment with the Reimer twins has been widely criticized by the scientific community for its unethical nature. Some critics have even claimed that his work has set back the progress of gender studies by decades. Despite this criticism, Money continued to defend his work throughout his career, refusing to acknowledge the harm he caused in the Reimer twins’ tragic life.
Where does the word gender come from?
The word gender has its roots in Latin, from the word “genus,” which means “kind” or “sort.” This word later evolved in Middle English and Old French to refer to the grammatical categorization of words as masculine, feminine, or neuter.
However, in the modern sense of the term, gender has taken on a broader meaning beyond grammar. It now refers to the social and cultural roles, behaviors, and identities that are associated with being male or female, or a combination of both. The term gender is used to describe the socially constructed roles, attitudes, and expectations of masculinity and femininity, rather than just the biological differences between sexes.
Gender theory suggests that gender is not just a biological characteristic, but rather a social construct influenced by cultural and historical factors. It is a fluid and dynamic concept that can change over time and across cultures.
In recent years, the term gender has also been expanded to include non-binary and gender non-conforming individuals who do not identify with traditional male or female gender roles. This recognition of a diverse range of gender identities has led to a greater understanding of the complex and nuanced nature of gender, and the need for inclusivity and respect for all individuals regardless of their gender identity.
Who are the Reimer twins?
The Reimer twins were the subject of a landmark case study in psychology and gender identity. Born in Canada in 1965, Bruce and Brian Reimer were identical twins who were both circumcised during a medical procedure shortly after they were born. Tragically, there was a complication during Bruce’s circumcision that left him with severe damage to his penis.
In a misguided attempt to remedy the situation, Bruce’s parents agreed to have him undergo a sex reassignment surgery and raised him as a girl named Brenda.
For years, researchers and clinicians cited the Reimer case as evidence that gender identity was largely determined by socialization and upbringing, rather than biology. Brenda fully embraced the feminine identity that was forced upon her and underwent hormone therapy as a teenager in an effort to increase her femininity.
However, the experience was incredibly traumatic for Brenda and she struggled with depression and suicidal thoughts throughout her life.
In the late 1980s, Brenda learned the truth about her past and made the decision to transition back to living as a male. He changed his name from Brenda to David and underwent hormone therapy to masculinize his body. David explained that he never felt like he fit in with the female gender identity that was forced upon him and always felt like something was missing.
Despite the doctors’ predictions that he would never be able to identify as male again, David successfully transitioned and eventually became an advocate for transgender rights.
The Reimer case has since been used to highlight the importance of patient autonomy, informed consent, and sensitivity to unique cultural and personal factors in medical decision-making. It also played a significant role in the broader discussion around gender identity and challenged long-held assumptions about the roles of nature and nurture in shaping gender identity.
When did gender first start being used?
The use of gender as a concept dates back to ancient times, but the modern understanding of gender emerged during the 20th century. In ancient cultures, gender roles were often defined by biological sex, with men being viewed as the dominant gender and women being viewed as submissive and inferior.
During the 1800s, social and political movements like the women’s suffrage movement and the Civil Rights movement led to a greater focus on the idea of gender equality. The concept of gender as a social construct began to emerge as people began to recognize that biological sex does not define one’s gender identity.
It was during the mid-20th century that the term “gender” gained widespread usage in academic and social circles. Psychologist John Money was among the first to use the term to describe the social and cultural aspects of masculinity and femininity, separate from biological sex. This led to the development of the field of gender studies, which seeks to understand how gender impacts society and how we can work to achieve greater gender equality.
Today, the concept of gender continues to evolve and change. Many people now recognize a wider range of gender identities beyond just male and female. The idea of gender as a binary construct is being challenged and more people are embracing the idea of gender as a spectrum. Gender continues to play a major role in our lives, and understanding its history and evolution is critical to achieving a more just and equitable society.
How does evolution explain gender?
Evolutionary theory suggests that gender differences exist due to natural selection and sexual selection, driven by reproductive success. In other words, males and females have evolved different physical and behavioral characteristics to increase their chances of mating and producing offspring.
From an evolutionary perspective, males and females have different reproductive strategies. In general, males seek to mate with as many partners as possible to increase their chances of passing on their genes, while females invest more time and energy in their offspring to ensure their survival. This leads to differences in physical traits, such as size and strength, as well as behavioral traits, such as aggression and competitiveness.
One of the most significant differences between genders is the presence of sex chromosomes. In mammals, males have one X and one Y chromosome, while females have two X chromosomes. This difference in chromosome makeup leads to differences in the development of sexual organs and secondary sexual characteristics, such as facial hair or breasts.
Evolution also explains gendered behavior through the concept of mate choice. In most species, females are more selective about their mates than males, as they invest more time and energy into producing and raising offspring. This leads to males competing for female attention and resources, often through displays of strength or aggression.
The evolutionary perspective on gender suggests that differences between males and females are adaptations to optimize reproductive success. While societal norms and cultural expectations can influence gendered behavior and roles, these traits have biological roots that can be traced back to evolutionary history.
What is gendered history?
Gendered history refers to the study and interpretation of history through the lens of gender, which recognizes gender as a central social and cultural construct, influential in shaping institutions, ideologies, and behaviors throughout history. It examines how gender, including masculinity and femininity, has been constructed, performed, and experienced at different times and places.
Gendered history reveals how gender shapes the lives and experiences of people, both historically and contemporarily.
Gendered history is concerned with exploring how gender has intersected with race, class, sexuality, and other inequalities in the past. In particular, it focuses on how gender roles and expectations have influenced power relations in society, shaping opportunities and limitations for people based on their gender identity.
This means looking beyond binary notions of male and female, and acknowledging the diversity of gender identities and expressions across cultures and time periods.
Some important themes in gendered history include the history of women, gender and work, gender and sexuality, gender and politics, gender and representation, and gender and war. Gendered history also analyzes how gender has been used to justify and perpetuate discrimination, violence, and oppression, and how gender has been used in resistance movements to challenge and transform unequal power relations.
Gendered history helps us better understand how gender shapes societies and cultures, and how it has impacted the lives of individuals throughout history. It provides invaluable insights into the complexity of gender relations, and how they change over time, which is essential in breaking down gender-based inequalities and creating more inclusive societies.
