Determining whether a Buffalo Nickel is rare or not typically requires an evaluation by a qualified coin collector or numismatist. It is important to note that the condition of the coin plays a major part in how rare and valuable it is considered.
The mint location, and the type or variety. The most common Buffalo Nickels are from the years 1913, 1914, and 1915 and they typically sell for no more than $20 – $25. Buffalo Nickels with the ‘D’ mint mark (they were made in Denver) have a slightly higher collector value but it is still not significantly more than the typical examples.
The overall condition of a Buffalo Nickel will also have a significant impact on its rarity. Coins that have been well-maintained and are in mint state (also known as “MS”), very fine (“VF”), or extremely fine (“EF”) condition generally will be of greater value than coins that have been damaged, scratched, or circulated.
Finally, there are a few varieties of Buffalo Nickels which are considered rare and valuable. The most valuable of these are the 1913-S (with the ‘S’ indicating it was made at the San Francisco Mint), and the 1918/7-D (which has a small D mint mark above the date).
These coins sell for thousands of dollars even in lower grades.
In conclusion, the rarity of Buffalo Nickels varies significantly depending on the year, mint location, condition, and variety. Conducting research or having an experienced numismatist examine your coin should provide you with a better value assessment.
Table of Contents
How do I know if my Buffalo nickel is worth money?
The best way to determine if your Buffalo nickel is worth money is to have it professionally appraised. You can look for a numismatic (coin specialist) near you who can assess the condition and authenticity of your Buffalo nickel and provide you with an estimated value.
Common factors which affect the value of coins include the age, condition, rarity, and the demand of the particular coin. Your coin will be graded on a scale of 1-70, with the higher number indicating a higher quality coin.
You can also find resources online to help you approximate the worth of your Buffalo nickel. However, the most reliable way to know if your Buffalo nickel is worth money is to have it appraised by a professional numismatic.
What years of Buffalo nickels are worth money?
The Buffalo nickel, also known as the Indian Head nickel, was a copper-nickel five-cent piece minted by the United States Mint from 1913 to 1938. Over these 25 years, several different varieties of Buffalo nickels were issued.
Many of these varieties are considered distinct from one another and are actively sought after by collectors.
The most common (and least valuable) Buffalo nickels are usually dated from 1913 to 1937. These nickels tend to trade for only a few dollars, depending on the condition and particular year.
Meanwhile, the most valuable Buffalo nickels are usually from the 1937-D 3-Legged variety, the 1918/7-D overdate, or the 1913-S. Depending on their exact variety and condition, these coins can be worth several hundred to several thousand dollars.
In addition, some errors and varieties from the 1930s, like the 1936 Doubled Die Obverse and the 1937-D 3-Legged, can be worth up to tens of thousands of dollars.
What nickels are worth saving?
When it comes to saving nickels, it depends on the year and condition of the coin. Generally, any nickels minted before 1964 are worth saving as they contain a higher percentage of silver. Any in excellent condition can be worth significantly more.
Some of the rarer nickels, such as the 1939 Jefferson Nickel, can be worth hundreds or even thousands of dollars. Other key dates in many nickel series can be worth a substantial amount if they are in great condition.
It is important to research each coin beforehand to get an idea of its potential value.
In addition to high value rarities there are also certain nickels composed of steel or using a Westward Journey design which can be worth slightly more than face value. Any collector looking for higher value nickels to save should focus on key dates and grades, as well as varieties that are rarer or made of unusual materials.
Why should I start hoarding nickels?
First, due to their low face values, nickels are a great way to build up a large amount of change over time and cultivate a habit of saving. Even if you just add a few nickels to your piggy bank every day, you can build up a sizable coin collection relatively quickly.
Additionally, nickels are a slightly more valuable form of currency than pennies, so it’s a good way to add more value to your piggy bank. Finally, nickels can be a valuable way to diversify your coin collection, which is especially helpful if you’re trying to collect coins for a particular year or with a certain mint mark.
Regardless of whether you’re looking to build up your savings or diversify your collection, hoarding nickels is a great way to get started.
What dates to look for on nickels?
If you’re referring to U. S. nickels, or Jefferson nickels, there are several key dates to look for when collecting mint-condition coins. The most sought-after date is 1913, which features a Liberty Head design, the only one ever produced.
Because only five were ever minted, this rare nickel can fetch several thousand dollars in an auction. Other key dates to watch for are: 1923-S, 1924-S, 1926-S, 1936-S, 1937-D, and 1942/1 Overdate (some nickels made in 1942 have a small “1” hammered over the top of a “2”).
Many collectors also seek out the 1938-D 3-legged buffalo nickel, and all of the scarce wartime nickels, minted between 1942 and 1945, which are composed of 56% copper, 35% silver, and 9% manganese.
What are the $100 most valuable nickels?
The top 100 most valuable nickels consists of dates and mint variations from the Shield Nickel issued from 1866 to 1883, Liberty Nickel issued from 1883 to 1912, Buffalo Nickel issued from 1913 to 1938, and Jefferson Nickel issued from 1938 to present.
The Shields nickels that are the most valuable are 1867 (no rays), 1868 (no motto), 1869 (with diamonds), 1870 (with arrows), 1877 (with reeded edge), and 1883 (no cents).
The Liberty nickels that are the most valuable are 1883 (no cents), 1884 (large 4), 1885 (no cents), 1886 (with rays), 1912 (with designer’s initials), and 1912-S (with designer’s initials).
The Buffalo nickels that are the most valuable are 1913 (no designer’s initials), 1913-D (no designer’s initials), 1913-S (no designer’s initials), 1916-D (with doubled die reverse), and 1918/7-D (overdate).
The Jefferson nickels that are the most valuable are 1938-D (with 3-legged buffalo), 1950-D (with over mintmark), 1950-S (with extremely strong doubled die reverse), 1951-S (with doubled die reverse), and 1964-D (with strong double die reverse).
What makes a 1935 buffalo nickel valuable?
The 1935 Buffalo Nickel is an incredibly collectible nickel from the United States Mint, and is a highly sought-after coin in the numismatic community. First, it is an important part of American history and a reminder of the wild west, featuring a powerful portrait of a Native American on the obverse and an American bison on the reverse.
Second, it is one of the first coins struck by the U. S. Mint with a living person on the obverse, making it a special, unique piece of memorabilia. Third, the 1935 Buffalo Nickel has a limited mintage, with only 33 million produced – compared to the over 100 million minted in 1936.
Finally, the appeal of the 1935 Buffalo Nickel is further enhanced by the two different varieties – the “Type 1” with no mint mark and the “Type 2” with a mint mark – making it a valuable, collectible item.
What are the key nickel dates?
The key nickel dates refer to some of the most valuable and rare nickel coins in existence. Depending on the grade of the coin, these key nickel dates can be worth thousands of dollars each, making them highly sought after by collectors.
The key dates include:
1913 Liberty Head Nickel: Often referred to as a “V” nickel, this coin is one of the rarest and most expensive American coins. It was created in limited quantities and only five specimens are known to still exist, making it a rare and highly valuable coin.
1910-S Liberty Head Nickel: Another valuable coin, the 1910-S Liberty Nickel is also considered to be a key date, although it can be found in higher grades than the rare 1913 Liberty Head Nickel.
1912-S Liberty Head Nickel: This coin is fairly difficult to find in any grade, and is therefore valuable to collectors.
1915-S Liberty Head Nickel: This nickels is more common than the other key dates, but is still valuable for its age and historical significance.
1937-D 3 Legged Buffalo Nickel: This coin was accidentally minted without the fourth leg on the front side of the coin, making it a rare and valuable find.
What is the error on the buffalo nickel?
The error on the buffalo nickel involves a design flaw in the initial release of the nickel, leading to a number of incorrect versions being produced. It is commonly referred to as the “split tail feathers” error because the design elements of the bison’s tail feathers were incorrectly placed.
Specifically, the second and third feather on the right-hand side of the tail were meant to be bisected, with the top of one touching the bottom of the other, creating a more realistic appearance. However, the mint mistakenly left a gap between the two feathers, making it appear as if the tail had four feathers, rather than three.
In addition, the two feathers on the left side of the tail were incorrectly pointed towards the center of the bison’s body, rather than towards the back. This error was corrected in 1906, but many of the incorrect versions were distributed, making them a highly sought-after collectible.
Should you keep Buffalo nickels?
Yes, you should keep Buffalo nickels! Not only are these coins from an era with an interesting place in American history, but these coins also have the potential to be worth more than their original face value, making them a great investment.
Buffalo nickels were minted from 1913-1938, making them a classic collectible and a truly timeless piece of American history.
These coins feature the iconic profile of an American Buffalo on one side, which was designed by James Earle Fraser. On the reverse side of the coin is a depiction of an American Indian wearing a feathered headdress.
This design has been used on many modern American coins, such as the state quarters.
Because of their historical significance and the potential for their value to increase over time, Buffalo nickels make a great addition to any coin collection. Although these coins are typically worth only face value if they are in poor condition, coins that are in better condition can be sold for a much higher price.
Investing in coins can be a great hobby for anyone with an eye for history and an interest in collecting rare and valuable items. You can start building your collection of Buffalo nickels today, and you may be able to increase the value of your collection over time.
How rare is a three legged Buffalo Nickel?
A three legged Buffalo Nickel is an extremely rare coin. It is believed that only a handful of three legged buffalo nickels were ever actually minted. The most notable known specimen is one in which a die clogged with dirt and grease caused the design on one side to be completely blocked out.
This coin is highly sought after by collectors and can command a high price if it was to come up for sale. The exact number of three legged buffalo nickels that were put into circulation is unknown, but it is believed that there are less than 10 of them in existence.
How much is a 1935 Indian head nickel with a buffalo on the back worth?
A 1935 Indian head nickel with a buffalo on the back is usually worth around $2 to $7, depending on its condition. Uncirculated coins in mint condition may sell for as much as $200 or more. To determine the exact value of a 1935 Indian head nickel with a buffalo on the back, it is important to assess the coin’s condition and determine any minor details that could affect the coin’s worth.
With knowledge of a coin’s condition and eye appeal, an accurate assessment of the coin’s overall worth can be made. Additionally, factors such as rarity, mintage figures, type, and other historical details can further contribute to a coin’s value.
It is recommended to consult a coin appreciation professional if you are ever unsure of a coin’s value.
What year of nickels should you look for?
The year of a nickel will depend on when it was minted. Nickels minted since 1866 have all been five-cent coins with similar obverses, but the reverse designs have varied greatly. Every few years, the Mint has issued special commemorative designs featuring iconic symbols from American culture.
The best way to identify the year of a nickel is to look for the mint mark. This is a letter, number, or symbol that indicates where the coin was minted. Before 1968, the mint mark was located on the reverse side of the coin and after 1968 it was placed on the obverse.
On United States nickel coins, the mint mark is usually preceded by the words “United States of America. ” Here are the locations and marks of the United States coins mints:
• Philadelphia (no mark).
• Denver (D).
• San Francisco (S).
• West Point (W).
• Manila (M).
You can also look at the date the coin was minted. This is located on the obverse side, usually near the Liberty Bell. Nickels minted in the United States have always had the year of mintage included on the obverse.
In conclusion, the year of a nickel can be identified by looking for the mint mark or date of mintage on the obverse or reverse side of the coin. Knowing which mints and dates the coin was minted will help determine the year of the nickel.
What nickels should I keep?
When it comes to collecting and saving nickels, there are a variety of nickels that are worth looking for and keeping. Generally, any coin that was minted before 1965 is made of silver, and you’ll want to look for these “silver nickels” including Liberty Head nickels and Buffalo nickels.
Additionally, there are a few other more modern nickels that are relatively uncommon and therefore worth more than a typical nickel, such as: Wartime Nickels (1942-1945), Jefferson Nickels with a “D” or “S” mint mark (made at the Denver or San Francisco mint, respectively), and nickels with errors (such as incorrectly stamped dates, or die varieties).
Finally, you may also want to look out for any nickels issued in special commemoration, such as the Westward Journey Nickel Series or the Bicentennial issue nickels. All of these types of nickels should be carefully evaluated and kept if they seem to be of value.
