Skip to Content

Why didn t Tom Riddle become an Obscurial?

Tom Riddle, also known as Voldemort, did not become an Obscurial because he was not suppressing his magical abilities. Obscurials are typically young wizards or witches who have been repressed or abused for their magical abilities, causing them to suppress their magical powers until they become uncontrollable and manifest as a destructive force known as an Obscurus.

Tom Riddle was a highly skilled and powerful wizard from a young age. He didn’t have to suppress his magic because he embraced it and used it to his advantage without any external forces to stop him. In fact, Riddle was known for his exceptional magical abilities and his desire to become the most powerful wizard of all time.

Furthermore, Obscurials typically do not live past their early teens due to the extreme physical and emotional strain caused by the Obscurus. Tom Riddle, on the other hand, lived well into his adulthood and continued to use his magic to achieve his devious goals, indicating that he did not fit the criteria of an Obscurial.

Tom Riddle did not become an Obscurial because he was not suppressing his magical powers and did not meet the criteria of a typical Obscurial. He was a highly skilled wizard who embraced his abilities and used them to his advantage in his quest for power and domination.

Could Harry Potter have been an Obscurial?

Harry Potter could have potentially been an Obscurial, based on the lore established in the Harry Potter universe. An Obscurial is a magical individual whose powers have been repressed and suppressed by the trauma of being forced to hide their magical abilities. This can occur when they live in environments or cultures that are hostile towards magic or when they are discouraged from developing their gifts due to societal norms or family beliefs.

In Harry’s case, he was raised by his Muggle aunt and uncle, who were decidedly anti-magic. They did their best to quash Harry’s innate magical powers, keeping him in a cupboard under the stairs and denying him any access to knowledge or practice of magic. This could have easily caused him to develop into an Obscurial if he was not already one.

However, there are some factors that make it unlikely that Harry was actually an Obscurial. For one, most Obscurials do not make it past the age of 10, as the suppression of their powers can cause them to implode and die young. But Harry survived well into his teenage years, which would be highly unlikely if he was an Obscurial.

Additionally, Harry had access to some level of magical education at Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry, which would have likely helped to keep his powers in check and develop them in a more healthy way.

Overall, while Harry could have potentially been an Obscurial due to his upbringing, it is more likely that he was not one given his survival into adulthood and his access to magical education.

Was there a Obscurial in Harry Potter?

Yes, there was an Obscurial in Harry Potter. In the second Fantastic Beasts movie, “Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald,” the character of Credence Barebone is revealed to be an Obscurial. An Obscurial is a dark magical force that forms inside a young witch or wizard who has been forced to repress their magical abilities due to persecution or abuse.

The repressed magic becomes so powerful that it manifests itself as a destructive force that can harm both the child and others around them.

Credence was a young wizard who had been adopted by a non-magical family that mistreated him and forced him to suppress his magical abilities. This repression caused him to become an Obscurial, with the force of the Obscurus constantly fighting to break free from inside him. In “Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald,” it is revealed that Credence is the lost biological brother of Albus Dumbledore and that this connection makes him a key player in the ongoing battle against the dark wizard Gellert Grindelwald.

Credence’s storyline as an Obscurial is a tragic one, as he struggles to come to grips with his powers and the forces that are controlling him. His journey is emblematic of the broader themes of repression and trauma that run throughout the Harry Potter universe, and his ultimate fate raises important questions about the nature of power and freedom in the wizarding world.

Overall, while Credence’s storyline as an Obscurial is a dark and turbulent one, it adds a layer of complexity and depth to the Wizarding World and underscores the power and dangers of dark magic.

Did Voldemort have an Obscurus?

Obscurials are individuals who repress their magical abilities as a result of abuse or trauma, creating a powerful and destructive force known as an Obscurus. According to Fantastic Beasts and where to find them, Obscurials are generally young wizards or witches who are unable to control their magic, and their emotional turmoil ultimately leads them to develop the Obscurus.

Based on this definition, it is highly unlikely that Voldemort had an Obscurus, as he was not a young wizard but a full-grown wizard when he began his reign of terror. Moreover, according to the Harry Potter books, Voldemort never struggled with controlling his magic, and he was consistently portrayed as an incredibly powerful wizard, able to perform magic that others could only dream of.

It can be argued that Voldemort went through significant emotional trauma as a child, which could have contributed to the development of an Obscurus. However, nothing in the books or movies ever suggested that Voldemort repressed his magical abilities as a result of abuse, which is a key characteristic of Obscurials.

Instead, Voldemort’s drive for power and domination was rooted in his desire for immortality and control, which had nothing to do with repressed magic or an Obscurus.

Therefore, while it is possible that Voldemort could have had an Obscurus, based on the definitions and characteristics established in the wizarding world, it is highly unlikely. There is no evidence that Voldemort ever struggled with controlling his magic or repressed his abilities as a result of trauma, making it improbable that he had an Obscurus.

Is Dumbledore an obscurus?

No, Dumbledore is not an obscurus. An obscurus is a dark and uncontrollable magical force that is generated when a young wizard or witch suppresses their magical abilities due to trauma or abuse. It manifests itself as a parasitic entity that feeds on the suppressed magic and threatens to destroy the host’s life.

Dumbledore, on the other hand, is one of the most powerful wizards of all time and has always been in control of his magical abilities. He is known for his wisdom, kindness, and intelligence, and has dedicated his life to fighting dark wizards and defending the wizarding world.

While Dumbledore did have a troubled childhood, where he was subjected to abuse by his younger sister Ariana’s uncontrolled magic, he never suppressed his own magical abilities. Instead, he learned to control and harness his magic to protect himself and those he loved.

Furthermore, Dumbledore’s association with Grindelwald, who was obsessed with the Dark Arts and sought to establish a wizarding dictatorship over non-magical people, does not make him an obscurus. Although Dumbledore was initially drawn to Grindelwald’s charisma and intellect, he ultimately realized the error of his ways and became a fierce opponent of Grindelwald’s ideology.

Dumbledore is not an obscurus. He is a powerful and ethical wizard who has dedicated his life to upholding the values of the wizarding world and protecting it from dark forces. His story reminds us that while everyone may have their own struggles and challenges, it’s how they choose to respond to them that defines who they are.

Was Ariana Dumbledore an Obscurial or a squib?

There is no clear evidence or confirmation in the Harry Potter canon to suggest that Ariana Dumbledore was either an Obscurial or a squib, leaving her true magical status open to interpretation.

An Obscurial is a wizard or witch who has repressed their magical abilities so drastically that it manifests as a dark and powerful force, known as an Obscurus. This occurs in young magical children who have been forced to suppress their magic due to persecution or mistreatment. While Ariana was surely traumatized by her ordeal with Muggle boys who had discovered her magical abilities, there is no direct evidence that she actively repressed her powers, nor is there any indication that she displayed the violent, destructive tendencies characteristic of an Obscurial.

On the other hand, a squib is a person born into a magical family who fails to inherit the ability to perform magic. Squibs are often treated as outcasts by the wizarding community and may feel a sense of shame or inadequacy due to their lack of magical abilities. Given that Ariana was the younger sister of powerful wizards Albus and Aberforth Dumbledore, it is possible that she struggled to keep up with their magical talent and felt isolated as a result.

However, there is no concrete evidence to suggest that she was incapable of performing magic altogether.

While it is tempting to speculate on Ariana’s magical status, there is simply not enough information available to make a definitive determination. Her tragic life story is a reminder of the dangers of societal prejudice and the importance of embracing and celebrating diversity, both in the wizarding world and in our own.

What’s the difference between an Obscurus an Obscurial?

An Obscurus and an Obscurial are both related to a rare and dangerous magical condition that occurs in young witches and wizards. However, there is a significant difference between the two.

An Obscurus is a parasitic entity that forms within a young witch or wizard’s body in response to the suppression of their magical abilities. This usually occurs when the child is forced to hide their powers due to persecution or fear of discovery. The Obscurus feeds on the child’s negative emotions such as anger, fear, and sadness, and ultimately takes over their body, causing destruction and chaos before eventually killing the child.

On the other hand, an Obscurial is the witch or wizard who is hosting the Obscurus within their body. They are the ones who are suppressing their magical abilities due to external factors such as societal pressure, persecution, or abuse. This leads to them becoming mentally and emotionally unstable, and their Obscurus takes over their body, causing uncontrollable outbursts of magic.

To put it simply, an Obscurus is a magical entity that forms within an Obscurial’s body, and an Obscurial is the witch or wizard who is hosting the Obscurus. An Obscurial is a victim of circumstance and suppression, while the Obscurus is the one causing destruction and chaos.

In essence, an Obscurus is a symptom of the suppression of a young witch or wizard’s magical abilities, while an Obscurial is the person affected by that suppression. Understanding the difference between the two is important in recognizing and treating this dangerous condition that affects such a vulnerable population.

Did Grindelwald know Credence was an obscurus?

There is no definitive answer as to whether or not Grindelwald knew that Credence was an Obscurus. However, based on his actions in “Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald,” it is possible that he did know.

Firstly, Grindelwald shows a significant interest in Credence throughout the film. He seeks him out, sends his followers to track him down and eventually meets with him directly. This implies that Grindelwald knows there is something special about Credence.

In addition, Grindelwald has a close relationship with Nagini, who is the only other known Obscurial in the Wizarding World at the time. This suggests that he is familiar with the concept of an Obscurus and the power that they possess. Given that Credence is also an Obscurus, it is reasonable to assume that Grindelwald would be aware of this fact.

Furthermore, Grindelwald’s actions towards Credence suggest that he understands the potential power that an Obscurus possesses. He attempts to manipulate Credence into joining his cause by using his Obscurial powers as a bargaining chip, implying that he knows the extent of their power.

Finally, in the climax of the film, Grindelwald recognizes that Credence is the only one capable of defeating Dumbledore, which suggests that he is aware of the full extent of Credence’s powers.

While there is no concrete evidence that Grindelwald was aware of Credence’s status as an Obscurus, the evidence from the film strongly suggests that he did know.

Did Credence know he was the Obscurial?

Credence, the tortured and abused adopted son of Mary Lou Barebone from Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, did not initially know that he was an Obscurial. An Obscurial is a type of dark magical parasite that forms within a young wizard or witch who suppresses their innate magical ability due to societal or familial pressure.

The parasite feeds on the repressed magic until it eventually takes over the host’s body, causing it to release uncontrollable power and often resulting in the host’s death.

Throughout the course of Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, Credence displays symptoms of being an Obscurial, including bursts of seemingly uncontrollable magical power, fits of rage, and self-loathing due to his inability to control his magic. He is initially identified as a potential Obscurial by Newt Scamander, who recognizes the telltale signs of the condition.

It is important to note that Credence’s adoptive mother, Mary Lou Barebone, is a staunch anti-witchcraft activist who has instilled a deep sense of shame and fear in Credence regarding his magical powers from a young age. As a result, Credence was never taught how to control his magic or even understand what it was; this suppression ultimately led to the manifestation of his Obscurial.

Credence’s discovery of his identity as an Obscurial is a pivotal moment in Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them. Though he initially believes that he is an illegitimate child of the powerful wizard Percival Graves, it is later revealed that Graves is really the villainous Gellert Grindelwald in disguise.

Grindelwald manipulates Credence into releasing his Obscurus, offering to help him harness his powers in exchange for his allegiance.

While Credence does not know from the outset that he is an Obscurial, the symptoms and circumstances surrounding his life ultimately lead to the manifestation of the parasitic creature. It is only through the intervention of Newt Scamander and the eventual revelation of Grindelwald’s true motives that Credence is able to learn the truth about himself and his dangerous power.

Does Dumbledore know that Credence is his brother?

There is no concrete evidence to suggest that Dumbledore knows that Credence is his brother. In the film “Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald,” Dumbledore does mention that he knows who Credence is and that he has a connection to him. However, he does not explicitly say that he knows they are brothers.

It is also important to note that Dumbledore’s relationship with his brother, Aberforth, was strained and complicated, and it is possible that he may not want to acknowledge a new familial connection at this point in his life. Additionally, Dumbledore may be holding back information for strategic reasons, as he often operates in a very calculated and secretive manner.

It is also possible that the revelation of Credence’s true identity as a member of the Dumbledore family could be saved for future films or books, as the “Fantastic Beasts” franchise is planned to span five movies.

Overall, while there are hints and suggestions that Dumbledore may be aware of his connection to Credence, there is no definitive answer and further exploration of their relationship is likely to be revealed in future installments of the franchise.

Did Grindelwald lie to Credence about being a Dumbledore?

No, Grindelwald did not lie to Credence about being a Dumbledore. Although Credence did not know the truth at first, Grindelwald hinted to Credence that he was related to the Dumbledore family and that they shared common ancestry.

In an effort to gain Credence’s trust, he revealed that he was “Gellert Grindelwald, an orphan no more, Albus Dumbledore’s brother”. He then tried to convince Credence that they were related by using “the power of the Obscurus that Credence has”.

However, when Credence learned the truth, which was that Grindelwald was actually related to Albus’ father and not a Dumbledore by blood, Grindelwald admitted that he had misled Credence. He implied that he did so because he was desperate for Credence to join his cause and to be able to rely on Credence’s power in his fight against those who opposed him.

What did Grindelwald tell Credence?

In the movie “Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald,” the villain Grindelwald had a crucial conversation with the protagonist Credence Barebone. It was revealed that Credence was not a no-maj, but rather a pure-blood wizard who was believed to have been born from a Dumbledore sibling.

Grindelwald explained to Credence that he was not alone in the magical world and that he had a place in it. He told Credence that he was a powerful being who had the potential to change the course of the wizarding world. Grindelwald also revealed to Credence that he had the power to control his magic and could harness it to do great things, something that Credence had never been taught.

Grindelwald also promised Credence that he would help him find out the truth about his past and family, something that had been a mystery to him all his life. However, Grindelwald had ulterior motives as he knew that Credence was the key to finding Albus Dumbledore’s weakness, and therefore he wanted to use him to defeat his arch-nemesis.

Grindelwald’s words instilled a sense of belonging and purpose in Credence, which made him more susceptible to Grindelwald’s manipulations. Grindelwald’s message to Credence was that he was special, and through his power and unwavering loyalty to Grindelwald, he could achieve great things.

Overall, Grindelwald’s conversation with Credence was instrumental in turning him against his former allies and becoming a pawn in Grindelwald’s plans for domination.

Why didn t Aberforth raise Credence?

Aberforth Dumbledore was a man of profound character and morality, helping many in the wizarding world, but he had no known connection to Credence Barebone. Aberforth was the brother of Albus Dumbledore, who was the headmaster of Hogwarts School of Witchcraft and Wizardry. Aberforth was committed to guarding and protecting the Cursed Child, Ariana Dumbledore, who was his sister, in secrecy.

He had no known children, and there is no evidence to suggest that he was involved in the adoption or upbringing of Credence.

Credence Barebone was a young wizard who was revealed to be the adopted son of Mary Lou Barebone, the leader of the New Salem Philanthropic Society, an anti-witchcraft movement in America. Mary Lou was a stern and abusive woman who raised Credence along with her other adopted children under the belief that witchcraft was an abomination.

Credence was born with magical abilities, which were suppressed by Mary Lou, leaving him vulnerable and repressed.

It is possible that Aberforth was unaware of Credence’s existence, as the events of Fantastic Beasts and Where to Find Them, where Credence’s story was told, took place in America. Additionally, Aberforth’s involvement with anything related to Albus Dumbledore or the wider wizarding world was never seen, making it less likely that he had any direct access to information about or interest in Credence.

Moreover, even if Aberforth knew about Credence and his hardship, it is essential to understand that raising a child is not something one can simply undertake because they feel it is the right thing to do. It requires a significant emotional, financial, and intellectual investment, and one must have the proper resources before taking on such a responsibility.

Aberforth was a wizard in his fifties during the events of Harry Potter, and there is no evidence that he had any wealth or resources that would have been sufficient for him to provide Credence with the care, education, and resources he required.

Aberforth Dumbledore did not raise Credence Barebone because he had no known connection to him, and there is no evidence that he was involved in the adoption or upbringing of Credence. Furthermore, taking on the responsibility of raising a child requires specific resources and investments, and it is not a decision that one can make lightly.

Thus, it is safer to say that Aberforth had no connection with Credence for these reasons.

Is Credence Snape’s grandfather?

There is no definitive answer to whether Credence is Snape’s grandfather as it has not been confirmed in the Harry Potter canon. However, there are several reasons why people have speculated that this may be the case.

Firstly, Credence is revealed in the Fantastic Beasts movies to be the long lost Dumbledore brother, Aurelius. This revelation was a surprise to many, as it had not been hinted at previously. It is possible, therefore, that Credence could be related to other characters in the Harry Potter universe, such as Snape.

Secondly, Snape is a character who is shrouded in mystery and is known to have had a difficult childhood. Very little is known about his parents, and so it is possible that Credence could have been related to them in some way.

There are several theories about how this could be possible. One theory is that Credence could have been the child of a love affair between Snape’s mother and a member of the Dumbledore family. This would mean that Snape’s mother had an affair while married to Snape’s father, possibly leading to the family breakdown that left Snape’s childhood so traumatic.

Alternatively, it is possible that Credence is the illegitimate child of Snape’s father. This theory is less well supported, as there is no evidence to suggest that Snape’s father had any relationship with the Dumbledore family. However, it is not impossible that Credence could be Snape’s grandfather if Snape’s father had a child with a woman from the Dumbledore family.

Overall, while there is no concrete evidence that Credence is Snape’s grandfather, there are several theories and possibilities that could explain this. It will be interesting to see if J.K. Rowling ever confirms or denies this theory in the future.

Why didn t the Qilin bow to Newt?

The Qilin is a mythical creature in Chinese folklore, widely known for its benevolent nature and revered as a symbol of good luck and prosperity. It is believed that the Qilin bows only to those who possess great wisdom, goodness, and purity of heart. So, when it comes to the question of why the Qilin did not bow to Newt, there could be several explanations.

Firstly, it’s important to understand Newt’s character and the context in which he encountered the Qilin. Newt Scamander is a fictional character from the Harry Potter universe, a renowned wizard, and a skilled magizoologist who specializes in magical creatures. In the 2018 movie Fantastic Beasts: The Crimes of Grindelwald, Newt comes face to face with the Qilin while on a mission to find Credence Barebone, a young wizard with immense power.

Now, while Newt is undoubtedly a talented wizard and an expert in his field, he does not necessarily possess the qualities that the Qilin looks for in a person. Newt has his share of flaws and quirks, including his awkwardness in social situations, his tendency to break rules, and his sometimes disorganized and chaotic way of doing things.

While these traits may add to his charm and appeal, they do not necessarily make him a paragon of virtue or wisdom.

Another factor to consider is the Qilin’s behavior in the movie. It is shown as a creature that is both majestic and proud, with a strong sense of its own worth and dignity. When Newt encounters the Qilin, he tries to approach it with kindness and respect, but the creature does not seem impressed or moved by his gestures.

It could be that the Qilin simply did not see Newt as someone worthy of its admiration, or that it had other reasons for not bowing to him.

Lastly, it’s important to remember that the Qilin is a mythical creature, and its actions are not always subject to rational or logical explanations. The Qilin’s behavior is often shrouded in mystery and symbolism, and it is often interpreted in different ways by different people. Some may view its refusal to bow to Newt as a sign of his unworthiness or lack of virtue, while others may see it as a test of his character, or a lesson in humility and respect for powerful beings.

The reason why the Qilin did not bow to Newt remains open to interpretation, and it is ultimately up to the viewer to decide what it means. It could be that Newt simply did not meet the Qilin’s high standards, or that the creature had its own reasons for behaving as it did. Regardless, the encounter with the Qilin serves as a reminder that greatness is not easily earned, and that true wisdom and virtue are rare and precious qualities.

Resources

  1. Had Dumbledore not brought Tom Riddle to Hogwarts … – Quora
  2. Why Harry Potter Didn’t Develop An Obscurus, According To …
  3. Voldemort is an Obscurial : r/harrypotter – Reddit
  4. Why Didn’t the Dursleys Turn Harry into an Obscurial?
  5. Was Tom Riddle an obscurus? – 2023 Calendar Canada