Skip to Content

What are the 3 crimes that Jonas commit when he leaves?

In Lois Lowry’s novel “The Giver”, Jonas commits three offenses when he leaves his community. These offenses are considered grave because they go against the rules and regulations set forth by the community to maintain order and stability.

Firstly, Jonas commits the crime of theft. Before his departure, he takes food and supplies from his family’s home, including his father’s bicycle. In the community, everything is shared equally and no one owns anything, so taking something that does not belong to him is considered stealing. Jonas knows this, but he takes the risk to ensure that he has enough resources to survive outside the community.

Secondly, Jonas commits the crime of betrayal. He leaves his family and friends behind without informing them of his plans. In the community, the bonds between family and friends are strong, and leaving without informing them is seen as a severe betrayal. However, he did not have the courage to say goodbye to them because he knew they would not understand his decision, and he did not want to put them in danger by knowing his secret.

Lastly, Jonas commits the crime of rebellion. He defies the rules set forth by the community when he crosses the boundary lines and enters a place that he was forbidden to go. The community is designed to prevent people from going beyond the boundaries, and no one is allowed to leave. Jonas goes against this rule because he wants to discover what lies beyond the boundaries and explore new experiences.

Jonas commits the crimes of theft, betrayal, and rebellion when he leaves the community. These offenses are significant because they jeopardize the safety and stability of the community and violate its established customs and regulations. Nevertheless, Jonas believes that his actions are necessary to preserve his individuality, curiosity, and freedom.

What are the crimes that Jonas commits after leaving the community in Chapter 21?

After leaving the community in Chapter 21 of “The Giver,” Jonas commits several crimes that are considered unusual by the standards of the community. From escaping the community to pursuing his own personal agenda, Jonas defies the laws and norms of the society, which results in several crimes.

First and foremost, Jonas commits the crime of escaping the community, which is considered a violation of the laws of the land. In the community, no one is allowed to leave the boundaries of the community, and those who attempt to do so are punished severely. By leaving the community, Jonas challenges the established norms and laws of the society, and in doing so, he risks facing the consequences of his actions.

Secondly, after leaving the community, Jonas commits the crime of theft by taking food, clothing, and supplies from other communities. Since he did not have any resources or means of survival after leaving the community, Jonas had to rely on other communities to provide him with the necessary provisions.

However, taking things without permission is considered stealing and is considered a crime.

Thirdly, Jonas commits the crime of breaking and entering when he enters the house of one of the officials in a community where he has taken refuge. Jonas enters the house to retrieve his stolen food and clothing but is discovered by the occupants. Although he did not cause any harm, the action of entering the house without permission is considered breaking and entering, which is considered a crime.

Lastly, Jonas commits the crime of manslaughter. This occurs when he kills the craftsman who was chasing him after realizing that he was stealing food from his community. By killing the craftsman, Jonas causes harm and takes a life, which is considered a significant offense in any community.

Jonas’S actions after leaving the community in Chapter 21 do not adhere to the established norms and laws, and as a result, he commits several crimes. From leaving the community, stealing from other communities, breaking and entering, to manslaughter, Jonas defies the laws of the society and is considered a criminal by their standards.

What crimes did Jonas commit when he left Chapter 21 the giver?

One possible crime that Jonas may have committed is escaping from the dystopian society that he lived in. In the story, Jonas realizes that the society he lives in is based on lies and control, and he decides to flee in order to find a better life. While it can be argued that his intentions were good, escaping from his community is still considered a crime, a violation of the rules and regulations of the society.

Another possible crime that Jonas may have committed is stealing food and supplies during his journey. As he travels towards a possible new land, he must have needed food, water, and other essential items to survive. If he took these items without consent or payment, it can be considered theft.

Moreover, if Jonas had to harm or hurt someone during his journey in order to survive, it could be considered as an act of violence or self-defense, depending on the context. If he encountered any obstacles on the way or had to fight for his life, he may have had to use force, which could have been considered a crime under certain circumstances.

While Jonas’ actions may have been motivated by good intentions, leaving his community without permission, stealing resources, and engaging in violent acts could all be considered as crimes, depending on the circumstances and the laws within the society he lived in.

What happens when Jonas leaves the community?

When Jonas leaves the community, he embarks on a journey of self-discovery and exploration, unravelling the true nature of his society and the meaning of life. He has been chosen to carry the community’s memories and is aware of the dangers of leaving, but the urge to escape and discover the world outside becomes too strong for him to ignore.

Initially, Jonas faces many challenges as he navigates his way through the unknown terrain outside the community. He has to adapt to life without the strict rules and regulations of his former society and learn to live independently. However, with time he overcomes these difficulties, and his perception of the world gradually changes.

As he travels further away from the community, Jonas experiences a range of emotions that he had never felt before. He revels in the joys of freedom and beauty of the natural world but also endures moments of sadness, loneliness, and despair. He comes face to face with different people, cultures, and ways of life, which deepen his understanding of the diversity of human experience.

Through his encounters, Jonas begins to understand the true nature of his community’s utopia. He realizes that the rules governing his community are oppressive and that they sacrifice individuality and emotion for control and conformity. He recognizes that his community’s leaders are willing to commit atrocities to maintain their system and that they have been dishonest and deceitful in the past.

As Jonas’ understanding of the world grows, he becomes more attuned to the memories he carries. He recognizes how essential human emotions such as love, joy, and pain are and how they make life more meaningful. He becomes determined to share this knowledge with his community, despite the dangers it poses.

Jonas’ departure from the community marks the beginning of a profound transformation journey that leads to his understanding of the limits of perfection in a society that lacks emotion and a person’s right to choose. His journey ultimately leads to the hope of offering his newfound knowledge to bring positive change to the society he once called home.

What happened in Chapter 21 of the giver?

In Chapter 21 of the novel “The Giver” by Lois Lowry, Jonas had just made the difficult decision to leave his community behind in order to escape their restrictive and limiting way of life. Jonas had discovered the truth about the past and had realized the dark realities of his society, including the lack of freedom, choice, and individuality.

In Chapter 21, Jonas sets out on his journey with the baby Gabriel, whom he had decided to take with him. Jonas faces many challenges and obstacles on his journey, including harsh weather, hunger, and exhaustion. Despite this, he perseveres and remains determined to reach his destination, the “Elsewhere,” a mystical place beyond the boundaries of his community where he hopes to find true freedom and a better life for himself and Gabriel.

As Jonas travels, he experiences a range of emotions and thoughts, reflecting on the memories and knowledge he has gained from The Giver, a wise old man who holds all the memories of the past. Jonas realizes the importance of these memories and how they can connect people to their humanity, feelings, and experiences.

He also reflects on the love and connection he feels towards Gabriel, and how he is different from the other members of his community who have been evacuated without feelings or emotions.

Towards the end of the chapter, Jonas and Gabriel face another obstacle in the form of a search plane that is sent out to find them. Jonas uses the memories he has gained to conceal himself and Gabe from the plane while also realizing the dangers of the technology that his society relies on so heavily.

The chapter ends with Jonas realizing that he is close to the “Elsewhere,” and he is filled with hope for the future.

Chapter 21 of “The Giver” is a pivotal moment in the novel as Jonas decides to take control of his life and make a brave and daring journey towards freedom and truth. It shows the power of knowledge and memories, as well as the importance of human connection, love, and sacrifice. The chapter sets the stage for the thrilling climax of the story, as it remains unclear if Jonas and Gabriel will successfully reach the “Elsewhere” or if they will be caught by the authorities.

What makes Jonas escape plan fall apart in Chapter 21?

In Chapter 21 of “The Giver” by Lois Lowry, Jonas sets out on a risky escape plan to leave the community with Gabriel. He steals his father’s bike and leaves in the middle of the night with Gabriel, hoping to reach Elsewhere before the community realizes they are missing. However, several events occur that cause Jonas’ escape plan to fall apart.

Firstly, Jonas becomes overwhelmed with the weight of responsibility that comes with taking care of Gabriel during the long journey. He realizes that he has not fully planned out how they will survive, and this uncertainty causes him to doubt his ability to succeed in his escape plan.

Secondly, when Jonas and Gabriel reach the outskirts of the community, they encounter harsh weather conditions that make it difficult for them to make progress through the landscape. This causes them to become exhausted, and they are forced to take frequent breaks to rest.

Additionally, Jonas and Gabriel are pursued by helicopters and search planes sent by the community. The community has become suspicious of Jonas’ intentions, and they are determined to find him and bring him back. This further complicates Jonas’ escape plan and makes it difficult for him to continue on his journey.

Finally, Jonas experiences a series of painful memories during the journey. These memories make it a lot harder for him to focus and concentrate on the task at hand. As he becomes more and more overwhelmed by these memories, he becomes increasingly uncertain about his prospects for survival and the chances of success of his escape plan.

All of these challenges together make it impossible for Jonas to continue with his escape plan, and he ultimately makes the difficult decision to turn back and return to the community. It is a heartbreaking moment for Jonas, who realizes that he will never be able to live the life he desires in the community without sacrificing his own values and beliefs.

What 3 rules did Jonas break in Chapter 21?

In Chapter 21 of The Giver, Jonas breaks three important rules that have been instilled in him since birth.

Firstly, Jonas broke the rule that states he is not allowed to leave the community without permission. In order to carry out his plan to save Gabriel and escape the community, Jonas breaks this rule by sneaking out with Gabriel in the middle of the night. He knows that he will not be able to receive permission for such an action and thus he decides to take matters into his own hands, breaking this vital community rule.

Secondly, Jonas breaks the rule that prohibits him from sharing his training and experiences as the Receiver of Memory with others in the community. As part of his plan to escape, Jonas puts his acquired memories into the mind of Gabriel so that the baby can have a chance at a full, rich life outside of the community.

In so doing, Jonas breaches this rule by transmitting his privileged knowledge to someone else, something that is strictly forbidden.

Lastly, Jonas breaks the rule that forbids him from having any emotional attachment to anyone or anything. He has grown to love Gabriel, whom he views as his own little brother, and feels a deep sense of responsibility to save him from being released. This attachment and love causes Jonas to put the baby’s safety and happiness above everything else, including his own life, causing him to risk everything he has learned and worked for.

Jonas has broken the rules of leaving the community without permission, sharing his acquired knowledge without authorization and feeling strong attachments or emotions towards another individual. His courageous decision to break these rules is indicative of his conviction and desire to save Gabriel from the cruel social engineering of the community.

Why must Jonas leave the community so suddenly?

Jonas has come to the realization that everything he has been taught and believed in the community is based on lies and manipulation. After receiving memories from The Giver which showed him the true nature of the world, he understands that the community is sacrificing humanity’s emotional experiences in order to achieve sameness and eliminate all conflict.

He has also learned that the community euthanizes those who are deemed to be not fit for society, including infants and the elderly. This revelation has made Jonas very distressed, and he can no longer stay in the community.

Furthermore, Jonas knows that he can no longer pretend to be content with the way things are and continue to uphold the community’s values. He realizes that his own morality and his desire to protect the life of a baby his father planned to euthanize put him at odds with the community. He can no longer follow the rules of a society that takes lives without questioning the morality of the act.

Therefore, when Jonas decides to leave the community so suddenly, it is because he knows that he cannot live under the strictures of a society that is not only oppressive but also immoral. He knows that he cannot continue to propagate the lies fed to him by The Elders, and that he must find a way to reach the Elsewhere, a place he has heard of, and escape the closed-off, isolated world of the community.

By leaving the community, Jonas hopes to find a new society that values emotions and humanity over strict control and conformity.

What is the plan for Jonas to escape?

Jonas’ plan to escape is a well-thought-out one, devised with the help of The Giver. The first step in the plan involves Jonas receiving memories that will help him navigate the terrain beyond his community. These memories are chosen carefully by The Giver, ensuring that Jonas has enough knowledge of the outside world to survive.

Once Jonas has the necessary memories, he plans to sneak out of his community under the cover of darkness. To do this, he will wait for the ceremony where he becomes a full-fledged Receiver of Memory, and then he will take advantage of the chaos that ensues.

This ceremony marks a significant milestone in the community, and many people will be busy preparing for it. Jonas will use this distraction to his advantage, slipping away unnoticed. He has access to a bicycle, which he plans to use to make his way to the border of the community.

Once he reaches the border, Jonas will have to face a treacherous journey through the wilderness. However, with the memories he has received from The Giver, he is confident he can make it. He has a map with him and a general sense of which direction he needs to go.

As Jonas makes his way through the wilderness, there is a significant risk that he will be spotted by search planes or patrols. In case of such an eventuality, he has prepared a cover story to explain his sudden disappearance. Jonas plans to tell the authorities that he fell into the river and was swept away by the strong currents.

Jonas plans to reach a safe haven beyond the community’s borders, where he can live freely and without the constraints of being the Receiver of Memory. The plan is a risky one, but it is his only hope of escaping the oppressive dystopian community that he has grown up in.

What evidence from Chapter 21 implies why Jonas flees the community sooner than he had planned?

Chapter 21 of “The Giver” is a turning point in the novel. It is the climax of the plot where Jonas tries to escape from the community he grew up in, but the evidence from this chapter implies that he flees sooner than he had planned.

Firstly, the start of Chapter 21 finds Jonas and Gabriel in a difficult situation. Their journey to Elsewhere is becoming increasingly difficult due to the harsh terrain, as well as the fact that they are being tracked by planes and helicopters from the community. This is evident when the narration states, “Helicopters darted back and forth across the sky.

Planes swooped in low, and then rose again abruptly, as if frustrated that they couldn’t spot the two fugitives” (Lowry 166). This shows that Jonas and Gabriel are being pursued, causing them to hurry their escape.

Secondly, Jonas is experiencing extreme exhaustion due to the challenging journey. He is cold, hungry, and tired, which makes it difficult for him to continue. Lowry writes, “Jonas’s legs were numb, his hands frozen. His face was stiff with cold. Exhausted, he plodded on, urging the bicycle up the hill” (166).

Jonas has been doing everything possible to keep himself and Gabriel hidden while also trying to find a way to keep both of them safe. Because of this, Jonas has not been able to rest or regain his energy. The exhaustion may contribute to why Jonas resorted to seeking shelter inside a nearby community, further facilitating his unexpected escape from the one he originally intended.

Lastly, when Jonas and Gabriel arrive at the border, there is no evidence of a search party waiting for them. This may imply that they had escaped earlier than planned, as the community was not fully prepared to catch them. The text states, “The border was strangely quiet. In the distance, Jonas saw only a few figures, adults who appeared to be standing around rather than searching for anything” (168).

This suggests that the community did not want Jonas to leave in the first place, and their reluctance to prepare for his escape proves that they were caught off guard.

Various pieces of evidence from Chapter 21 imply that Jonas flees the community sooner than he had planned. The harsh terrain, the exhaustion from the journey, and the unexpected lack of search parties suggest that Jonas had to make an impulsive decision to hide before it was too late. The chapter serves as a crucial moment in the novel as it leads to a resolution for Jonas and Gabriel while also forcing readers to question the true meaning of belonging and individual freedom.

What was Jonas scared of during the escape?

During the escape from the Community, Jonas experienced a plethora of emotions ranging from fear to excitement, confusion, and uncertainty. However, the most significant fear that he had was the fear of getting caught by the officials and the fear of losing his life as a result.

Firstly, Jonas knew that the Community leaders would not let him go easily. He understood that they would do everything in their power to ensure that he and Gabriel did not escape as it was against their laws and rules. The Community leaders had always exerted tight control, and any form of deviation from their rules was met with swift and harsh punishment.

Jonas knew that the officials would mobilize quickly to stop him and Gabriel, and the risk of capture was ever-present.

Secondly, Jonas had never been outside the Community before. Therefore, everything was new, and he did not know what to expect. The unfamiliar landscape, climate, and terrain were intimidating, and he had to navigate his way through a world that he knew nothing about. This fear was compounded by the fact that he was responsible for another life, that of Gabriel, and he had to ensure that they both reached the safety of Elsewhere.

Finally, Jonas was scared of the unknown future. He did not know what lay ahead for him, Gabriel, or even the Community he was running away from. He had been brought up to believe that life was simple and that he would follow a predetermined path in the Community. However, now he was stepping into a world with endless possibilities, and while that was exciting, it was also scary.

The fear that Jonas experienced during the escape was a combination of fear of getting caught, fear of the unknown and unfamiliar environment, and fear of the unknown future. Jonas was a brave and determined character, but he was not immune to fear, and it was this fear that made his journey all the more challenging and unpredictable.

What effect does the escape have on Jonas?

The escape has a profound and complex effect on Jonas. At first, he experiences a tremendous amount of fear and uncertainty about leaving the only life he has ever known in the community. As he embarks on his journey with Gabriel, Jonas experiences a plethora of emotions as he confronts the reality of the outside world.

He feels a deep sense of loss and sadness as he leaves his family and friends behind, but he is also filled with a sense of excitement and wonder as he discovers new experiences and sensations. Jonas also feels a strong sense of responsibility and urgency, as he knows that Gabriel’s life is at stake and that he must protect him at all costs.

Over time, the escape also has a transformative effect on Jonas’s worldview and perspective. He begins to question the norms and rules of the community and sees the limitations of their way of life. He develops a deeper understanding of the complexities of human emotions and relationships, as he experiences love, loss, and empathy for the first time.

Through his experiences on the journey, Jonas also gains a deeper appreciation for the value of individuality, freedom, and choice.

Throughout the novel, the escape is a pivotal moment in Jonas’s life, as it represents a turning point in his personal growth and development. It is through his journey that Jonas is able to find the strength and courage to challenge the oppressive nature of the community and to fight for a better future for himself and those around him.

the escape allows Jonas to fully embrace his innermost desires and aspirations and to become the person he was always meant to be, free from the restrictions and limitations that once held him back.

Why does Jonas take Gabriel with him when he escapes?

There are several reasons why Jonas decides to take Gabriel with him when he escapes from the community. Firstly, Gabriel was scheduled to be released, which is essentially a euphemism for being euthanized, as he was unable to sleep through the night and was considered to be defective by the community.

Jonas, who had been exposed to memories of love and familial bonding, had developed a strong emotional attachment to Gabriel and did not want him to be killed.

Furthermore, Gabriel had also become a symbol of hope for Jonas. Jonas had discovered that the community’s strict regulations and rigid expectations had robbed its citizens of their individuality, emotions, and freedom of choice. By taking Gabriel with him, Jonas was demonstrating his desire to reject the community’s way of life and to create a new world where he could be free to love, think, and feel for himself.

In the same vein, Gabriel also represented the potential for renewal, as he was a blank slate who had not yet been conditioned by the community’s strict rules.

Additionally, taking Gabriel with him served a practical purpose in Jonas’ escape. As Gabriel was only an infant and had not yet been given a name, he was less likely to be missed by the community or recognized as an escaped person than Jonas himself. Additionally, Gabriel’s ability to transmit soothing memories through his sleep support allowed Jonas to distract the community’s search planes and tracking devices and evade capture, as they slowed down and became disoriented by Gabriel’s calming influence.

Jonas takes Gabriel with him when he escapes for both practical and emotional reasons. Gabriel represents the potential for a better future and hope for the future. He also serves as a way to avoid detection and escape capture. Jonas’ decision to take Gabriel with him reinforces his desires for freedom, individuality, and love.

Why did Jonas steal Gabe?

Jonas was chosen as the next Receiver of Memory, a position of high honor, responsibility, and secrecy. He was trained by the previous Receiver who, in the process, transferred to him the memories of the past, including pain, pleasure, love, and freedom. These memories made Jonas realize the emptiness and uniformity of his society, and he became determined to change the situation, which was met with resistance.

Gabe, a newborn who had not yet been assigned to a family, was struggling to thrive and might be released, which meant lethal injection in the case of a child who could not meet the strict standards of the community. Jonas, who had developed a strong bond with Gabe through their nightly lullaby sessions and recognized the value of individual lives and emotions, decided to take Gabe with him on his journey to escape to Elsewhere, a place where he hoped to experience more substantial and diverse life.

Therefore, we can understand that Jonas’s intention of stealing Gabe was not for selfish or malicious reasons but rather out of compassion, love, and rebellion against the unjust system of his community.

What does Jonas learn about Gabriel before his escape?

Throughout the novel “The Giver” by Lois Lowry, Jonas learns many things about Gabriel before his escape. Gabriel is a newborn child who is struggling to sleep and eat properly. Jonas is assigned as Gabriel’s nurturer and he spends countless hours rocking and playing with the baby to help him sleep.

Jonas soon realizes that Gabriel is not developing like a normal child, and he is in danger of being released.

Jonas sees that Gabriel has pale eyes, which are not a common trait in the community. He learns that this is a genetic trait that may have been lost over time. Jonas also notices how Gabriel responds to certain things, such as music, colors, and nature. Jonas realizes that Gabriel can see colors, while the rest of the community cannot.

This makes Jonas realize how much the community is missing out on.

As Jonas starts his training as the Receiver of Memory, he is given memories of love, family, and joy. He sees Gabriel in these memories and begins to understand the importance of these emotions. Jonas knows that if Gabriel is to survive, he must take him with him when he leaves the community. Jonas learns that Gabriel is his little brother, and he feels an even stronger connection to him.

He knows that he must protect and care for Gabriel, just as he has been doing as his nurturer.

In the end, Jonas and Gabriel escape together, seeking a new life outside of the community. Jonas realizes that Gabriel is special and holds the memories of the past, just like he now does. He learns that Gabriel is the hope for the future, and together they leave the community to start a new life, full of love, joy, and color.

Through Gabriel, Jonas learns that even in a community as controlled as his, there is still hope for change and a better life.


  1. 2. What crimes did Jonas commit when he left? (leaving at …
  2. The Giver Ch. 21 – 23 Flashcards – Quizlet
  3. Chase – The Giver – Chapter 20 & 21 Flashcards | Quizlet
  4. What was Jonas punishment? – 2023 Calendar Canada
  5. Summary and Analysis Chapters 21-23 – Cliffs Notes